Long-term nonprogressors (LTNP) are defined as individuals
infected with HIV for longer than 10 years and showing
current CD4+ T-cells > 500 mm3 in the absence of antiretroviral
therapy. They represent ∼5% of all chronically
HIV-infected patients (Cao, et al. N Engl J Med. 1995;332:201-8).
According to levels of plasma viremia, two groups of LTNP
have been defined: (i) elite controllers, who are those able
to maintain undetectable levels of viral replication (HIV-RNA
< 50 copies/ml); and (ii) viremic controllers, who are those
with low but detectable levels of viral replication (Blankson,
et al. Immunity. 2008;29:845-7; Saksena, et al. AIDS Rev.
2007;9:195-207).
Long-term nonprogressors offer a unique model for investigating
potential host factors associated with HIV suppression.
Control of viral replication in LTNP has been associated
with lack of disease progression. Complex interactions
between distinct viral and host variables exist, involving both
genetic and immunologic factors (Pantaleo, et al. N Engl J
Med. 1995;332:209-16; Buchbinder, et al. Microbes Infect.
1999;1:1113-20; Saksena, et al. AIDS Rev. 2007;9:195-207),
which ultimately account for the LTNP behavior. HIV-specific
T-cell responses are one of the immunologic factors that have
received more attention, although a lack of consistent associations
between the frequency of HIV-specific T-cells and
control of viral replication suggest that not all T-cells are equivalent
and that the efficacy in controlling viral replication may
be largely dependent on qualitative parameters. Thus, the
search for determinants of T-cell efficacy in HIV infection is a
key goal.
The characterization of the differentiation phenotype of
T-cells and its correlation with distinct functions has been
assessed in multiple studies. However, none of them has been
able to define a specific T-cell differentiation stage associated
with protective antiviral function (Appay, et al. Cytometry A.
2008;73:975-83). Thus, the correlation between phenotype
and T-cell efficacy remains at best ambiguous. In one study
in which five functions of HIV-specific T-cells were examined,
LTNP showed poly-functional responses with a higher quality
than that seen in antiretroviral-naive individuals with progressive
HIV disease (Betts, et al. Blood. 2006; 107:4781-9).
However, HIV-specific T-cell responses do not seem to fully
explain viral suppression in these patients (López, et al. AIDS
Res Hum Retroviruses. 2008;24:1185-95; Emu, et al. J Virol.
2008;82: 5398-407). Moreover, different pathways (PD-1,
CTLA-4, Tim-3, AKT, etc.) are involved in the regulation of
antigen-specific cellular immune responses. At this time there
is scarce information about the involvement of these pathways
in the regulation of HIV-specific CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell
responses in HIV-infected persons.
The failure of the Merck vaccine trial, in which an experimental
vaccine designed to induce protective cellular immune
responses showed no benefit, points to the need for
a more detailed knowledge of the attributes of cellular immune
responses that are responsible for an efficient control
of viral replication. Two recent studies (Hadrup. et al. Nat
Meth. 2009;6:520-6; Newell, et al. Nat Meth. 2009;6:497-9)
have restored the interest for examining antigen-specific
CD4+ and CD8+ T-cell responses at levels of single cells. For
this purpose, the authors of those studies used a multiplex
analysis based on a combination of labeled histocompatibility
complex I and II multimers and polychromatic flow cytometry.
In single specimens, by this approach the researchers
were able to detect simultaneously T-cells with multiple specificities
(from 15 to 63) against cytomegalovirus, Epstein-
Barr virus, influenza, or melanoma. Moreover, when this
methodology was linked to functional analysis of specific
T-cells, the attributes that define the efficiency of antigenspecific
T-cell immune responses can accurately be predicted.
The methodology will allow screening of a broad array of
antigens such as HIV, HCV, and HBV, among others. On the
other hand, given the huge amount of data generated by this
new methodology, an immuno-bioinformatic analysis of data
arrays produced will be required. For this purpose, new
software, named flow analysis with automated multivariate
estimation (FLAME), has been developed (Pyne, et al. Proc
Natl Acad Sci USA. 2009;106: 8519-24) to permit a comprehensive
study of combinatorial multiplexed antigen-specific
T-cell responses.
No doubt this new technology will make it easier to conduct
studies addressing the attributes of HIV-specific CD4+ and
CD8+ T-cell responses involved in the control of viral replication.
These studies are necessary to identify the immune correlates
of viral replication control. This knowledge seems to
be crucial for regaining confidence in the rational design of
new HIV vaccine candidates. At this time, it seems convenient
to begin examining the different attributes of cellular immune
responses and the different pathways involved in their regulation
in patients spontaneously controlling HIV replication (elite
controllers), taking as reference patients with suppressed viremia
as a result of antiretroviral therapy and drug-naive persons
with typical HIV disease progression.
|